Marketing is, at its core, communication. It’s not just about how loud you shout — it’s about what you say, how you say it, and how the audience interprets it. When there’s a disconnect between a brand’s intended message and how that message is received by its audience, the results can be catastrophic.
This blog is a real case study from one of my clients — a company in the insurance sector — that lost over $1 million on Meta (Facebook & Instagram) ads due to one critical but overlooked concept: message encoding and decoding.
Despite having a solid product, significant budget, and talented people, the campaign failed simply because the audience misunderstood the ads. People thought they were clicking on ads for a dental clinic — not an insurance company. The results? High CPA (Cost Per Acquisition), irrelevant leads, poor ROAS (Return on Ad Spend), and a confused brand image.
Let’s dissect what went wrong, what marketers can learn, and how this can be avoided.
Before diving into the case, let’s break down these two concepts.
Encoding is the process by which a brand translates its ideas, positioning, and value proposition into words, images, and symbols used in communication. This includes:
Ad copy
Visual creatives
Color schemes
Fonts and layout
Branding elements
In advertising, the brand must encode its message clearly and consistently so that the audience can interpret it correctly.
Decoding happens on the receiver’s end — the audience interprets the message using their knowledge, expectations, context, biases, and assumptions.
Even if a message is encoded with precision, decoding is subjective and depends on how well the creative aligns with the target audience’s worldview.
If the encoding is poor, decoding will be wrong — and your entire campaign might go down the drain.
Our client is a well-established insurance provider offering personal, health, and business insurance products in the US. They decided to scale via Meta campaigns, allocating a massive $1 million advertising budget to reach a broader audience through Facebook and Instagram.
They had all the right intentions:
Product-market fit
Good customer base
Budget and team
Ambition to scale
But they missed one foundational marketing principle: communication clarity.
The internal marketing team developed several creatives and copy variations. The campaigns were structured for:
Conversions (lead forms and landing page visits)
Audiences segmented by age, income, and interest in financial products
Multiple ad sets, each with different value propositions
The ads had visuals like:
Smiling families
Dental chairs
Health professionals
The tagline: “Protect What Matters”
Sounds decent, right?
But here’s the twist — they used videos but that displayed as hospital not as insurance product.
Here’s where things started going downhill.
Most of the ads had:
Images of a dentist in a white coat
Dental chairs with overhead lights
Tools on trays
These images made perfect sense to the internal team — they wanted to convey “protecting health, well-being, and financial future.” But to the average consumer scrolling on Meta, these visuals screamed “dental clinic ad”.
Their main tagline was “Protect What Matters” — a noble but ambiguous phrase. To an insurance agent, it makes perfect sense. To the average user seeing a dentist in the image, it could mean dental protection plans, family dentistry packages, or cleanings.
No one outside the company knew they were offering comprehensive insurance — not dental services.
Users who clicked:
Thought they were booking dental appointments
Landed on a page offering insurance policies
Got confused and dropped off
The traffic quality plummeted. Bounce rates skyrocketed. Cost per lead soared. And worst of all — Meta’s algorithm got trained on the wrong audience.
Despite running the campaign for several months, the KPIs looked like this:
| Metric | Expected | Actual |
|---|---|---|
| CPA (Cost Per Acquisition) | $20–$30 | $170+ |
| CTR (Click Through Rate) | 2.5%+ | 0.9% |
| Bounce Rate | <40% | >70% |
| Qualified Leads | 5,000+ | <1,000 |
| Sales Conversion Rate | 10% | 1.2% |
Worse still, the brand started receiving emails and form fills from people asking:
“When is my dental appointment?”
“Do you offer teeth whitening?”
“Is this a free checkup?”
At one point, their CRM had more dental inquiries than insurance leads.
That’s $1 million — gone. Not because of bad targeting or platform inefficiencies, but because of miscommunication at the encoding level.
Meta’s AI-powered ad delivery system learns from user behavior. When early clicks came from people interested in dental care, the algorithm optimized delivery toward that profile:
Dental interest groups
Local health services seekers
Moms and families seeking pediatric dental care
This further amplified the misinterpretation.
Instead of course-correcting, the team doubled down on their spend, believing it was a volume problem. It wasn’t. It was a message clarity problem.
This case offers several critical insights for any marketer or brand manager.
Every image, color, font, and visual element communicates meaning. Stock photos of dental chairs don’t say “insurance” — they say “dental services.” Be intentional with every visual element.
Before launching a campaign at scale, test it with actual members of your target audience. Ask them:
“What do you think this ad is about?”
If the answer isn’t within 5 seconds — your message isn’t working.
“Protect What Matters” could mean:
Security systems
Dental plans
Car safety features
Life coaching
Use precise language. E.g., “Get Affordable Health & Life Insurance Today” immediately sets context.
The landing page must visually and contextually match the ad. If someone sees a dental chair and clicks, but lands on an insurance page with charts, they’re gone. Always maintain message consistency across the customer journey.
Meta’s algorithm is powerful — but it only works when fed the right signals. Early miscommunication causes algorithm misalignment, and correcting it takes time, money, and retraining — or starting over.
After diagnosing the failure, we helped the client relaunch with a new approach:
Replaced all visuals with insurance-relevant imagery: happy families holding insurance documents, people meeting with agents, policy binders, etc.
Used real photos from their office to establish trust.
New headline: “Health, Life & Business Insurance Plans Starting $99/Month”
CTA: “Get Free Quote”
Specific landing pages for each insurance vertical (health, business, life)
Removed irrelevant elements
Added explainer videos
New lookalike audiences based on past insurance customers
First-party data re-fed into Meta
Excluded dental interests from targeting
Ran $2,000 pilot to test decoding and behavior
Collected feedback from users on how they interpreted ads
Results over 60 days:
CPA dropped from $170 to $35
CTR improved to 3.1%
Qualified leads increased by 9x
Meta’s algorithm began learning correctly again
In marketing, what your audience sees and hears is all that matters. If you’re not in control of how your message is decoded, you’re gambling.
The $1 million loss was painful — but it taught a lesson more valuable than any ROAS metric could offer:
If the message isn’t clear, the market won’t care.
No amount of budget, tools, or optimization can fix a communication breakdown at the core. You must ensure that what you say, what you show, and what they understand are in perfect harmony.
Audit your messaging — ask strangers what your ad is about in 5 seconds.
Never rely solely on stock images — create or customize.
A/B test decoding, not just engagement.
Use language that eliminates ambiguity.
Watch how the algorithm behaves early — it’s telling you something.
Maintain message congruence across ad > landing > offer.
If your campaigns are underperforming, don’t just look at targeting or bids. Ask:
“Is the message encoded the way we want it to be decoded?”
Because that — and not the size of your budget — is what separates successful campaigns from million-dollar disasters.
Akshat’s passion for marketing and dedication to helping others has been the driving force behind AkshatSinghBisht.com. Known for his insightful perspectives, practical advice, and unwavering commitment to his audience, Akshat is a trusted voice in the marketing community.
If you have any questions simply use the following contact details.
